The Great Silence of the Desert
A parable concerning intelligent life, improbable journeys, and the peculiar expectation that somebody ought to have visited by now.
There was once an small tribe who lived in an oasis in an unfathomable desert.
We are discussing an otherwise quite adequate and respectable oasis, with palm trees, figs, freshwater springs, a vegetable gardens, goats, freshwater fish, a family of Hippo, pink birds that never went anywhere, fish a number of insects, and an elderly tortoise whose intellectual capacities remained a matter of disagreement.
Beyond the oasis stretched the Desert, far beyond measure.
The Desert was very large. Long hence a wise man had erected from the central hill a large tower of sticks and glanced aloft and seen how far and it was clear – many thousands of kilometers – strictly nothing but desert.
In fact, it was so extraordinarily large that nobody had the slightest idea how large it was beyond that. adventurous members of the tribe had explored its immediate surroundings for kilometers and established, to their satisfaction, that it consisted almost entirely of sand, rocks, rather more sand, and occasionally rocks pretending to be sand. Some had returned very thirsty, with scraped knees.
There was no particular reason to believe that the Desert ended anywhere.
There was, however, reason to believe that other oases existed, even if this was largely a theoretical assumption.
After all, their own oasis existed, and there was nothing obviously miraculous about it. Water gathered in depressions. Plants grew where water was available. Animals sometimes came to eat the plants. There was no compelling reason why this combination of circumstances should have occurred only once in the entire Desert.
Numerous wise man, who had a scientific disposition, proposed that there might be thousands of oases. There had been paintings of these conjectures in a cave under the Hill of Observations. One girl with a lot of fantasy and a propensity to chew a suspicious root suggested millions. Her son, who enjoyed large numbers and made a strong tea of that root, suggested ten thousand billion trillion. His mother advised everyone to stop arguing and stop the goats from chewing that root as they wandered off and occasionally fell over.
For several generations, The Wise Of The Cave Of Observations debated various matters pertaining to the Desert and its implications, cartographic and mathemathical.
They developed increasingly sophisticated observational tools, mathematical models, geological surveys, and a formidable collection of scrolls concerning the likely distribution of groundwater, and how upwelling geological formations might yield Oasis. This model had an uncanny predictable capability and it allowed for modest extension of agriculture around the Oasis by carefully creating wells. The wise established that some hypothetical oases might be too salty to support vegetation. Others Oasis might contain only algae. Some might support plants and insects. A smaller fraction of oasis might support a range of animals but it would not be guaranteed that somehow humans had emerged, been deposit there by The Gods or wandered there or sprung forth from the waters. Or evolved. Or whatever.
Who knows, given sufficient opportunities, some of those animals might conceivably become intelligent, thus “Evolution” as a thesis.
Indeed, it would stand to reason elsewhere there existed creatures who had discovered mathematics, agriculture, architecture, philosophy, and the production of unnecessarily complicated furniture, given a sufficiently large desert. And (meaningful gesture) were this not the case?
This left the people of the Oasis with a strangely frustration question….. The Desert remained eerily silent.
Eventually, the family’s descendants established the Institute for the Study of the Great Silence.
Its first director was a distinguished gentleman named Professor Harun, who wore a splendid white beard and had published seventeen papers on the probable characteristics of hypothetical desert civilizations.
One afternoon, Harun assembled his colleagues beneath the largest palm tree.
“Gentlemen,” he announced, “I have constrained the logical boundaries if this problem.”
Everyone looked appropriately concerned.
“Consider the unfathomable age of the Desert. It has existed for an unimaginably long time. We have studied geology … our oasis, by comparison, is comparatively young.”
He gestured toward the horizon.
“Now consider the probable existence of other oases. Some may have existed for millions of years before ours. Some may have supported intelligent creatures long before our ancestors learned to sharpen sticks.”
The scholars nodded.
“Such beings may have developed technology far beyond our own. We have extrapolated advanced technologies of wheels – a concept we can not yet fully conceive of but that we may one day develop – a chariot ...” (frightened whispered at the diagrams) “… and it is believed that with sufficiently advanced chariots and efforts, logistical chains, a generation caravan may cross to other oasis. This mere theoretical conception proves it can be done by a sufficiently advanced stage 1 Oasis civilisation. WE havent even properly reached stage one. ”
More nodding. “Of course” many nodded.
“And if even one such civilization developed this or any other reliable desert-crossing technology we may at this time not even conceive of, its inhabitants could establish settlements in other oases. Those settlements could themselves develop the same technology and establish further settlements. Of course there will never be flying through the air travel people always dream of in stories. That is simple fantastic fiction. Laws of nature preclude such travel. It is impossible. So we must remain realistic. We will always have to travel over the surface. ”
Harun drew a branching diagram in the sand.
“But even then, given sufficient time, a powerful Oasis Empire could spread throughout the entire Desert.”
He paused dramatically.
“Yet here we are. Alone.”
The scholars exchanged troubled glances.
“Therefore,” Harun concluded, “we must ask a terrible question.”
He raised one finger.
“Where is everybody?”
There was a long silence.
Then someone asked whether the professor had accounted for the possibility that the other oases were extremely far away.
“Certainly,” said Harun. “But that is merely a technological problem.”
“How far away?”
“We do not know.”
“How long would it take to reach one?”
“We do not know.”
“How many oases are there?”
“We do not know.”
“How many contain intelligent creatures?”
“We do not know.”
“How many intelligent creatures would wish to cross the Desert?”
“We do not know.”
“Then how do we know they should have reached us?”
Harun smiled patiently.
“Because the Desert is very old.”
This answer was considered profound.
As the years passed, the Great Silence became a matter of considerable academic anxiety.
One school of thought proposed that intelligent civilizations inevitably destroyed themselves shortly after discovering the means to cross the Desert.
Another suggested that intelligent creatures were naturally inclined to wage destructive wars, poison their groundwater, or manufacture machines that eventually murdered their inventors.
A third school maintained that advanced civilizations probably became so sophisticated that they abandoned physical existence altogether, retreating into elaborate dream worlds where they could spend eternity experiencing unimaginable pleasures.
A fourth suggested that the Desert was full of Misschievous Djinn who were deliberately hiding.
A fifth proposed that all the other oases had been conquered by an ancient and terrible civilization that destroyed any emerging Oasis before it could become a competitor.
This last theory was especially popular at conferences.
Professor Harun’s successor, Professor Tafil, developed an elegant concept called the Great Filter.
“The reasoning,” he explained, “is straightforward. Somewhere between the appearance of a simple plant and the establishment of a civilization capable of occupying the entire Desert, there must exist an extraordinarily difficult obstacle.”
He drew a series of boxes.
“Water. Plants. Animals. Intelligence. Technology. Desert crossing. Universal settlement.”
He tapped the final box.
“Since we observe no evidence that the Desert has been universally settled, at least one of these transitions must be extremely improbable.”
A young researcher raised her hand.
“Why is universal settlement the final box?”
“Because that is what sufficiently advanced civilizations would eventually accomplish.”
“Would they?”
“Some of them certainly would.”
“Why?”
“Because, given enough civilizations, at least one would.”
“And how do we know that?”
“Because otherwise we would have to explain why none had.”
The young researcher considered this.
“Couldn’t the final box simply be ‘a civilization exists and does whatever it happens to do’?”
Professor Tafil looked disappointed.
“That would make the model considerably less useful.”
Then came a remarkable discovery.
A geological expedition found evidence that another oasis might exist somewhere beyond the eastern horizon.
There was no direct proof. The expedition had recovered a small stone containing minerals that suggested prolonged contact with water, perhaps in conditions unlike those found locally.
The Institute erupted in excitement.
The evidence was ambiguous, but it opened a fascinating possibility.
Perhaps another oasis existed.
Perhaps it contained plants.
Perhaps those plants supported animals.
Perhaps, somewhere beyond the immeasurable dunes, life had arisen independently.
Professor Tafil was horrified.
“This,” he declared, “may be the worst news in the history of our civilization.”
The expedition leader stared at him.
“We found a damp rock.”
“Precisely!”
“Isn’t that good news?”
“Not necessarily. If plants can arise in multiple oases, then the emergence of life may be relatively easy. If life is easy, and yet no advanced civilization has reached us, then the Great Filter must lie somewhere beyond the emergence of life.”
He lowered his voice.
“Perhaps ahead of us.”
The expedition leader looked at the stone.
“So if there are plants elsewhere, we might all be doomed?”
“It is a possibility we must take seriously.”
“And if there are no plants elsewhere?”
“Then the Great Filter may lie behind us, which would be encouraging.”
“And if there are intelligent animals elsewhere?”
“Potentially catastrophic.”
“And if we find an actual intelligent animal?”
“That would be extremely alarming.”
The expedition leader thought about this for some time.
“So the more interesting the Desert turns out to be, the worse the news?”
“Under certain assumptions, yes.”
“Should we perhaps examine those assumptions?”
Professor Tafil frowned.
“That is what we have been doing for decades.”
Many generations later, the Institute had grown into an impressive institution.
It possessed excellent facilities, several rival departments, a substantial research budget, and a tradition of treating the Great Silence with the gravity it deserved.
The family had meanwhile become a thriving little society.
They had built homes, libraries, irrigation systems, workshops, and a pleasant café overlooking the northern spring.
They had also developed machines capable of traveling some distance into the Desert.
The machines were expensive, difficult to maintain, and generally broke down long before reaching anything interesting.
Nevertheless, progress was undeniable.
One evening, a young engineer named Samira attended a lecture entitled The Existential Implications of the Absence of Universal Desert Colonization.
The lecturer explained that the continued absence of visitors suggested several disturbing possibilities.
Perhaps intelligence was extraordinarily rare.
Perhaps technological civilizations invariably destroyed themselves.
Perhaps a hostile civilization patrolled the Desert and exterminated anyone attempting to expand.
Or perhaps the inhabitants of other oases had all reached some mysterious technological threshold beyond which their civilizations became permanently silent.
Samira raised her hand.
“How much of the Desert have we actually explored?”
“A very small proportion.”
“How small?”
“An exceedingly small proportion.”
“Could there be a million inhabited oases?”
“Certainly.”
“A million advanced civilizations?”
“Conceivably.”
“Could some of them have discovered desert crossing?”
“Yes.”
“Could some even have established settlements in other oases?”
“That is possible.”
“Could there be entire networks of settlements, trading with one another across thousands of miles?”
“Again, conceivable.”
“Could those networks have existed for millions of years?”
“We cannot exclude it.”
“And could all of that be happening without anyone ever reaching us?”
The lecturer hesitated.
“Well, depending on the distances involved…”
“Which we don’t know.”
“Correct.”
“And the number of oases.”
“Correct.”
“And the cost of traveling between them.”
“Correct.”
“And the actual behavior of their inhabitants.”
“Correct.”
Samira looked around the lecture hall.
“Then what precisely is the paradox?”
The lecturer took a drink of water.
“The paradox is that, given enough time, someone ought to have reached us.”
“Why?”
“Because eventually someone would develop the technology.”
“And then?”
“They would expand.”
“Why?”
“Because some civilizations would be expansionist.”
“And then?”
“They would establish settlements.”
“And then?”
“Those settlements would expand further.”
“And what if most of the Desert contains nothing whatsoever?”
“That would make expansion difficult.”
“What if the next oasis is so far away that reaching it requires centuries?”
“That would also present difficulties.”
“What if the inhabitants of an advanced oasis have plenty of resources and no particular interest in founding colonies?”
“Some might still be interested.”
“What if most colonies fail?”
“Some might succeed.”
“What if successful colonies don’t produce further colonies?”
“Some might.”
“What if crossing the Desert requires a tremendous investment that no subsequent settlement can easily reproduce?”
“That would complicate matters.”
“What if a civilization explored ten thousand oases and decided it had quite enough?”
“Others might continue.”
“What if they sent machines instead?”
“That is actually one of our strongest arguments.”
Samira considered this.
“All right. Suppose they build machines that can make more machines.”
“Exactly!” said the lecturer, brightening. “Self-replicating explorers! They could spread exponentially through the Desert.”
“Provided they can find the materials they need.”
“Yes.”
“And energy.”
“Yes.”
“And suitable places to build more machines.”
“Naturally.”
“And survive the journey.”
“Of course.”
“And reproduce reliably.”
“Certainly.”
“And not simply stop after completing their assigned surveys.”
“Presumably.”
“And the distances between suitable construction sites don’t make the whole process impossibly slow.”
“That would be relevant.”
“And at least one civilization actually builds such things and permits them to expand indefinitely.”
The lecturer sighed.
“Young lady, you are making an extraordinary number of objections.”
“I thought we were discussing the extraordinary absence of something.”
After the lecture, Samira walked to the northern spring, where her grandmother was feeding the tortoise.
She sat beside her.
“Grandmother, do you think there are other oases?”
“Almost certainly.”
“Do you think there are people in them?”
“I wouldn’t be surprised.”
“Do you think some are more advanced than us?”
“Considering how long the Desert has existed, I wouldn’t be surprised by that either.”
“Do you think some can cross the Desert?”
“Possibly.”
“Then why haven’t they come here?”
Her grandmother scattered some lettuce leaves.
“How many people live in our oasis?”
“About twelve thousand.”
“How many have ever attempted to cross the Desert?”
“Very few.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s dangerous, expensive, and we don’t know where we’re going.”
“And if we knew where another oasis was?”
“Some people might go.”
“And if it were a hundred years away?”
“Probably fewer.”
“And if it were ten thousand years away?”
Samira laughed.
“Nobody.”
“Nobody?”
“Well, perhaps someone. If we developed some extraordinary machine.”
“And suppose you did. Suppose you found another oasis after ten thousand years of traveling. What would you do?”
“Explore it.”
“And then?”
“Study it, I suppose.”
“And then?”
“Perhaps establish a settlement.”
“And then?”
“I don’t know.”
“Would your descendants necessarily spend the next hundred thousand years constructing machines to search for more oases?”
“Not necessarily.”
“Would their descendants?”
“Perhaps.”
“And would every settlement founded by every subsequent expedition behave the same way?”
“Probably not.”
“Would every expedition succeed?”
“No.”
“Would every machine continue reproducing forever?”
“Of course not.”
Her grandmother nodded.
“Then perhaps the Desert is very large.”
Samira looked out across the dunes.
“That’s your explanation?”
“It’s a possibility.”
“But the professors have written thousands of books about this.”
“Yes, dear.”
“Some of them think we may be the only intelligent creatures in the entire Desert.”
“Perhaps we are.”
“Some believe that every intelligent species eventually destroys itself.”
“Perhaps some do.”
“Some think an ancient civilization is exterminating everyone.”
“That would be unfortunate.”
“Some think the discovery of a second oasis containing a single living plant would suggest that a terrible catastrophe awaits us.”
Her grandmother stopped feeding the tortoise.
“Now that is a rather remarkable conclusion to draw from a plant.”
A few years later, Samira published a short paper.
It was entitled On the Unwarranted Expectation of Visitors.
Her argument was modest.
The existence of other oases did not establish the existence of intelligent inhabitants.
The existence of intelligent inhabitants did not establish the development of desert-crossing technology.
The development of desert-crossing technology did not establish a persistent inclination toward expansion.
Expansion did not necessarily imply exponential colonization.
And exponential colonization, even where possible, did not automatically establish that every oasis in an immeasurably large Desert would eventually be visited.
The observation that nobody had arrived at their particular oasis therefore placed constraints on certain combinations of these possibilities, but did not identify which, if any, had failed.
Most importantly, she argued, the apparent force of the Great Silence depended upon an assumption that rarely received the same scrutiny as the other assumptions.
That an advanced civilization would eventually regard the occupation of the entire Desert as a natural, probable, or inevitable outcome of its existence.
She suggested that this was an oddly specific expectation to impose upon hypothetical creatures whose existence, psychology, economics, technologies, and historical circumstances remained entirely unknown.
The paper attracted considerable criticism.
One reviewer complained that Samira had failed to appreciate the implications of exponential growth.
Another pointed out that even a single civilization committed to indefinite expansion could, under favorable circumstances, eventually occupy enormous territories.
A third observed that the age of the Desert was sufficient to accommodate many such expansions.
Samira agreed with all three.
She merely asked whether the favorable circumstances had been established.
The reviewers recommended rejection.
One wrote that her argument amounted to special pleading.
She replied that this was an interesting accusation from a discipline that had spent the better part of a century proposing universal civilizational suicide, invisible predators, mysterious technological transcendence, and hypothetical extermination machines to explain why nobody had arrived at a place whose position relative to any other inhabited oasis was entirely unknown.
The editor described her response as unnecessarily combative.
Years passed.
The Institute continued its work.
New generations of scholars developed increasingly sophisticated models of oasis formation, technological advancement, civilizational collapse, expansion dynamics, and the probability of intelligent life.
Some of those models were genuinely brilliant.
Some produced unexpected results.
Some demonstrated that, under reasonable assumptions, even extremely rare expansionist civilizations might spread astonishingly far.
Others showed that modest changes in the assumed distribution of oases, travel costs, or settlement survival rates could transform the predicted outcome.
The debate continued, as it should.
Then, one afternoon, the Institute received an extraordinary message.
A distant expedition had discovered another oasis.
It was small, rather muddy, and supported several species of moss.
There were no animals.
There were no buildings.
There were no intelligent inhabitants.
There was, however, unmistakable evidence that life had arisen independently.
The entire oasis celebrated.
People danced in the streets. Children waved little green flags. The cafés stayed open until dawn.
At the Institute, several senior scholars were deeply troubled.
Professor Tafil’s successor announced that the discovery might indicate that the Great Filter lay ahead.
Another warned that the probability of eventual civilizational extinction might have increased.
A third suggested that the moss represented an ominous development in the statistical distribution of life.
The newspapers carried alarming headlines.
SECOND OASIS DISCOVERED: EXISTENTIAL IMPLICATIONS UNCERTAIN
MOSS MAY INDICATE FUTURE CATASTROPHE
SCIENTISTS URGE CAUTION OVER EXTRATERRESTRIAL VEGETATION
Samira, now an elderly woman, read the reports over breakfast.
Then she went outside.
The Desert was enormous.
Somewhere beyond the horizon lay an oasis containing moss.
Perhaps there were ten more.
Perhaps there were ten million.
Perhaps there were civilizations so ancient and sophisticated that her own people would scarcely recognize their accomplishments.
Perhaps some had crossed the Desert.
Perhaps some had built extraordinary cities around distant springs, established trade routes across impossible distances, and spent a million years exploring worlds she could not imagine.
Perhaps entire histories of art, philosophy, love, warfare, discovery, reconciliation, and adventure had unfolded beneath skies no one in her oasis would ever see.
And perhaps not.
Nothing in the silence surrounding her oasis could settle those questions.
She watched the sunrise.
Behind her, a young man from the Institute approached.
“Professor Samira?”
“Yes?”
“I’ve been asked to interview you about the discovery.”
“How lovely.”
“Do you believe finding life in another oasis makes it more likely that our civilization faces an insurmountable Great Filter?”
“I believe it establishes that moss grows in another oasis.”
“But surely the discovery has implications?”
“Enormous implications. We now know life exists in two places.”
“And doesn’t that make our continued isolation more mysterious?”
“Not particularly.”
“But why has nobody come here?”
Samira considered the young man.
Then she pointed toward the eastern horizon.
“Tell me. Have you ever been to the other side of the Desert?”
“No.”
“Do you know what lies there?”
“No.”
“Do you know how far it extends?”
“No.”
“Do you know whether anyone lives there?”
“No.”
“Do you know whether anyone has ever attempted to cross it?”
“No.”
“Do you know whether anyone has succeeded?”
“No.”
“Then perhaps,” she suggested, “we should be careful about declaring their failure to visit us the greatest mystery in existence.”
The young man consulted his notes.
“But surely, given sufficient time, someone would eventually arrive?”
Samira smiled.
“Possibly.”
“And if nobody ever does?”
“Then nobody ever does.”
“But what would that mean?”
“It would mean we hadn’t been visited.”
He looked dissatisfied.
“That’s rather anticlimactic.”
“Yes,” she said. “Reality sometimes is.”
They stood together for a while.
Eventually the young man asked one final question.
“Professor, do you think we’re alone?”
Samira looked at the Desert, the palms, the water, the little homes along the spring, and the distant mountains disappearing into the haze.
“I have absolutely no idea.”
She seemed quite content with this.
The young man closed his notebook.
Somewhere nearby, the ancient tortoise was eating a leaf.
And beyond the oasis, extending in every direction, the Desert remained magnificently, extravagantly, and quite possibly misleadingly silent.
Nobody came.
Nobody had promised to.